What Kind of Citizen Are You?

In April 2004, Joel Westeimer (University of Ottowa) and Joseph Kahne (Mills College) published an article entitled, "Educating the 'Good' Citizen: Political Choices and Pedagogical Goals." In the article, they describe three types of citizens: (1) the Personally Responsible Citizen; (2) the Participatory Citizen; and (3) the Justice-Oriented Citizen.

(1)The Personally Responsible Citizen is the citizen that is primarily known for complying with any citizenship obligations he may have such as paying taxes and serving on a jury. He will likely pick up litter, give blood, and other do other forms of community service. The authors point out that this is the type of citizenship advocated by most school based service-learning programs, where the student is expected to find an existing service program and volunteer a certain number of hours per month or term. On one hand this type of citizen is honest loyal and committed to his fellow man. On the other hand, he may not be encouraged to engage in the critical reflection necessary for an engaged democratic society.

(2)The Participatory Citizen is engaged in community affairs and takes responsibility for planning the activities that engage the personally responsibile citizen. The participatory citizen is also familar with the workings of government, as he likely will cooperate with particular government agencies in his or her planning.

(3)The Justice Oriented Citizen is the citizen most driven by issues of injustice, and is most driven towards motivating others to actively address the injustice, along with seeking to address the root causes of whatever problem is being addressed.

Westeimer and Kahne stress ways in which young citizens are effectively taught that being patriotic means singing patriotic songs, saying the pledge of allegience, being nice to neighbors, and being personal responsible. Social movements, government policy and political engagement are simply ignored. In other words, citizens are encouraged to be highly active as engaged citizens, but only as Personally Responsible Citizen and occassionally as Participatory Citizens, whereas a truely fully engaged citizen is the Justice Oriented Citizen.

What kind of citizen am I? And more importantly, at what moment in time am I being asked this question?

Althouh Westeimer and Kahne did not say so directly, although I am sure they meant it, the fully engaged citizen plays all three roles at various stages of their life. For instance, in certain areas of my life I am the Justice Oriented Citizen, and in other areas of my life, I am the Personally Responsible Citizen. One simply does not have the ability to call out every form of injustice available.

More importantly, though, the fully engaged citizen exhibits all of these traits at various times of the week, and thus is really a balanced citizen. Thus, Westeimber and Kahne correctly point out that many young people are effectively discouraged from being fully active balanced citizens, and are encouraged to be only Personally Responsible Citizens.

As pointed out by the authors, this result is very problematic for a democracy. A democracy requires all three types of citizens, or requires all citizens to play each role in different occassions. If the population as a whole were to fail to produce any of these three types of citizens, I believe it would fail to exist, and would certainly fail to have any right to claim itself a democracy.

In fact, I believe that the strongest societies are those where all citizens take up the mantle of each citizen type depending on the situation, and that the diversity of skills and interests in society at large means that for the most part, people balance between differing roles based on their interests and skills. And thus, in a true democracy, almost all play all three roles throughout their lives.